Ethical and Legal Issues Archives - The Western Journal of Emergency Medicine

Ethical and Legal Issues

Emergency Department and Urgent Care Medical Malpractice Claims 2001–15

Wong, KE.

This study reviews malpractice, also called medical professional liability (MPL), claims involving adult patients cared for in emergency departments (ED) and urgent care settings.

Westjem Read More

Ethical and Legal Issues

HIPAA Versus CIPA (California Invasion of Privacy Act): Are Physicians Protected from Live Social Media Streaming in the Emergency Department?

Sawyer, MD, et al.

In the current age of ubiquitous Internet connectivity and the ability to share anything on social media at a moment’s notice, it is critical that physicians be aware of laws enacted to protect our safety and integrity as practicing clinicians in the 21st century.

Westjem Read More

Ethical and Legal Issues

Optimizing the Use of a Precious Resource: The Role of Emergency Physicians in a Humanitarian Crisis

Parveen K. Parmar, MD, MPH, et al.

Emergency physicians (EP) are uniquely suited to provide care in crises as a result of their broad training, ability to work quickly and effectively in high-pressure, austere settings, and their inherent flexibility. While emergency medicine training is helpful to support the needs of crisis-affected and displaced populations, it is not in itself sufficient. In this article we review what an EP should carefully consider prior to deployment.

Westjem Read More

Ethical and Legal Issues

Emergency Physicians as Good Samaritans: Survey of Frequency, Locations, Supplies and Medications

Volume 17, Issue 1, January 2015.
Taylor W. Burkholder, MD, MPH, et al.

Introduction: Little is known about the frequency and locations in which emergency physicians
(EPs) are bystanders to an accident or emergency; equally uncertain is which contents of an
“emergency kit” may be useful during such events. The aim of this study was to describe the
frequency and locations of Good Samaritan acts by EPs and also determine which emergency kit
supplies and medications were most commonly used by Good Samaritans.
Methods: We conducted an electronic survey among a convenience sample of EPs in Colorado.
Results: Respondents reported a median frequency of 2.0 Good Samaritan acts per five years of
practice, with the most common locations being sports and entertainment events (25%), road traffic
accidents (21%), and wilderness settings (19%). Of those who had acted as Good Samaritans, 86%
reported that at least one supply would have been useful during the most recent event, and 66%
reported at least one medication would have been useful. The most useful supplies were gloves
(54%), dressings (34%), and a stethoscope (20%), while the most useful medications were oxygen
(19%), intravenous fluids (17%), and epinephrine (14%).
Conclusion: The majority of EPs can expect to provide Good Samaritan care during their careers
and would be better prepared by carrying a kit with common supplies and medications where they
are most likely to use them.

Westjem Read More

Ethical and Legal Issues

Epidemiology of Advance Directives in Extended Care Facility Patients Presenting to the Emergency Department

Volume 16, Issue 7, December 2015.
Jessica Wall, MD, MPH, et al.

Introduction: We conducted an epidemiologic evaluation of advance directives and do-notresuscitate
(DNR) prevalence among residents of extended care facilities (ECF) presenting to the
emergency department (ED).

Methods: We performed a retrospective medical record review on ED patients originating from an
ECF. Data were collected on age, sex, race, triage acuity, ED disposition, DNR status, power-of
attorney (POA) status, and living will (LW) status. We generated descriptive statistics, and used
logistic regression to evaluate predictors of DNR status.

Results: A total of 754 patients over 20 months met inclusion criteria; 533 (70.7%) were white, 351
(46.6%) were male, and the median age was 66 years (IQR 54-78). DNR orders were found in 124
(16.4%, 95% CI [13.9-19.1%]) patients. In univariate analysis, there was a significant difference in
DNR by gender (10.5% female vs. 6.0% male with DNR, p=0.013), race (13.4% white vs. 3.1% nonwhite
with DNR, p=0.005), and age (4.0% <65 years; 2.9% 65-74 years, p=0.101; 3.3% 75-84 years,
p=0.001; 6.2% >84 years, p<0.001). Using multivariate logistic regression, we found that factors
associated with DNR status were gender (OR 1.477, p=0.358, note interaction term), POA status
(OR 6.612, p<0.001), LW (18.032, p<0.001), age (65-74 years OR 1.261, p=0.478; 75-84 years OR
1.737, p=0.091, >84 years OR 5.258, P<0.001), with interactions between POA and gender (OR
0.294, P=0.016) and between POA and LW (OR 0.227, p<0.005). Secondary analysis demonstrated
that DNR orders were not significantly associated with death during admission (p=0.084).

Conclusion: Age, gender, POA, and LW use are predictors of ECF patient DNR use. Further, DNR
presence is not a predictor of death in the hospital.

Westjem Read More

Inferior Vena Cava Filter Fracture: Potential Liability for Emergency Physicians

Volume 16, Issue 2, March 2015
Richard M. Pescatore, DO et al.

A 58-year-old female presented to the emergency department complaining of low back pain following a motor vehicle crash.

Westjem Read More

Ethical and Legal Issues

Do Emergency Physicians and Medical Students Find It Unethical to ‘Look up’ Their Patients on Facebook or Google?

Volume 16, Issue 2, March 2015
Maxim Ben-Yakov, MD et al.

The use of search engines and online social media (OSM) websites by healthcare providers is increasing and may even be used to search for patient information. This raises several ethical issues. The objective of this study is to evaluate the prevalence of OSM and web-searching for patient information and to explore attitudes towards the ethical appropriateness of these practices by physicians and trainees in the emergency department (ED).

Westjem Read More

Ethical and Legal Issues

Effects of a Dedicated Regional Psychiatric Emergency Service on Boarding of Psychiatric Patients in Area Emergency Departments

Volume XV, Issue 1, February 2014
Scott Zeller, MD et al.

This study sought to assess the effects of a regional dedicated emergency psychiatric facility design known at the “Alameda Model” on boarding times and hospitalization rates for psychiatric patients in area EDs.

Westjem Read More

Ethical and Legal Issues

The Alameda Model: An Effort Worth Emulating

Volume XV, Issue 1, February 2014
Aimee Moulin, MD, et al.

In 2009 Alameda placed 11.0 involuntary holds per 1,000 population, while the next highest county in California only placed 6.4 per 1,000 population.5 This may suggest instead that some of Alameda’s mental health patients would not have been placed on an involuntary hold in other California counties in the first place, increasing the proportion of lower acuity psychiatric emergencies and thus accounting for the high discharge rate.

Westjem Read More

Ethical and Legal Issues

Response to Moulin and Jones: “The Alameda Model: An Effort Worth Emulating”

Volume XV, Issue 1, February 2014
Scott Zeller, MD

As Moulin and Jones correctly indicate, there is no delineation of the relative acuity of the study patients to those seen in other emergency settings in California. However, we are unaware of any established metric to provide such a comparison for this patient population, and no such categorization was noted in any of the other boarding time studies cited in the article.

Westjem Read More

Ethical and Legal Issues

Increasing Suicide Rates Among Middle-age Persons and Interventions to Manage Patients with Psychiatric Complaints

Volume XV, Issue 1, February 2014
Bharath Chakravarthy, MD, MPH et al.

The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) has published significant data and trends related to suicide rates in the United States (U.S.). Suicide is the 10th leading cause of death in U.S. adults, and rates are increasing across all geographic regions. There is a significant increase in the suicide rate among adults in the 35–64 age range. We present findings from the CDC’s Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report (MMWR) with commentary on current resources and barriers to psychiatric care.

WestJEM Read More

Ethical and Legal Issues

Patient Attitudes Regarding Consent for Emergency Department Computed Tomographies

Volume XV, Issue 1, February 2015
Michael B. Weigner, MD et al.

Little is known about patient attitudes towards informed consent for computed tomography (CT) in the emergency department (ED). We set out to determine ED patient attitudes about providing informed consent for CTs.

WestJEM Read More